Orange Coast Magazine

Taste of O.C. | Priscilla Mayfield on food


Original Fish Company's New Seal Beach Pier Spot

Work starts now on the vision of approachable, something-for-everyone food and comfortable surroundings

The Seal Beach pier may be getting a new restaurant to replace the Ruby’s that closed more than a year ago, but we’ll have to wait a while to dine there. The new Off the Hook, to be operated by Seal Beach residents Wendy Rothman and Vanessa Rothman-Travis, the mother-daughter team that has owned the Original Fish Company in neighboring Los Alamitos for more than 30 years, could be 18 months in the making.

“It’s very early days,” says Rothman-Travis, who adds that building on the pier adds many factors to the already lengthy list required of any restaurant opening. “We’ve just started talking to the city, and a lot will be up to the Coastal Commission. But it has to be right. We want it to look right, to feel right, to be welcoming to locals and to visitors, too. We live here, and we like the small-town, quaint feeling.”

In keeping with that, Rothman-Travis sees the new place as inclusive in every way including price. “What appeals to me is doing a place that can be more everyday—affordable, with great food in a great environment.” The picturesque pier has the environment side covered, and Rothman-Travis has ideas for the food. “We’ll bring over some of the classics from Fish Company, like the shrimp cocktail, the chowder, and the bread bowls. But the menu won’t be seafood focused—there’ll be fish tacos, but also a chicken sandwich, a great hamburger, pasta dishes, and will be real kid-friendly.”

Her original restaurant, of course, is mostly about seafood. “People think of Fish Company as special occasion,” she says, “and it is—we’re putting the highest-priced, highest-quality proteins on the plate.” The Los Alamitos institution will continue doing just that—in fact, in two weeks it will undergo an extensive remodel that will add banquet facilities, enlarge the fish market to three times its current size, and install what Rothman-Travis describes as a “massive” bar that’ll have sports on TV and its own menu.

Sounds like the co-owners have plenty to keep them busy during the long lead-up to Off the Hook on the pier.

(Photo by Instagram user balance1lbc.)


Leave a comment:

· Subscribe to comments
Be the first to comment here.

OC Guides


OC Guides
  • Best of 2014: Honey Bee Chicken

    You’ll fall in lust with the chicken pieces at BBQ Chicken at Diamond Jamboree in Irvine. Fried in olive oil for a crunchy exterior, they’re tossed in a sweet honey sauce making them all the more delicious. $11 to $21

    Read More
  • Best of 2014: New York Pizza

    Seal Beach’s A Slice of New York makes pizza the way it’s supposed to be—with a thin, chewy crust that oozes cheese and can be enjoyed the New Yawker way: folded in half.
    142 Main St., 562-493-4430,

    Read More
  • Best of 2014: Bird-Watching

    When the throngs of beachgoers are too much, spend a day with the birds. Here, with the wind whipping off the ocean and herons, egrets, ducks, and more soaring above, you'll get a chance to be the amateur ornithologist you never knew you wanted to be. Free
    3842 Warner Ave., Huntington Beach, 714-846-1114,

    Read More
  • Best of 2014: Green Cleaners

    Sold from her website and a refitted retro travel trailer, these earth-safe cleaning products are Marilyn Nowak of Coto de Caza's propriety formulas. Products for laundry, surfaces such as glass and wood - even an ecological drain cleaner - all have dispenser bottles and bulk refills $8 to $48
    Resuming in September at Great Park Farmer's Market, Sand Canyon Avenue and Marine Way, Irvine, 949-292-1648,

    Read More
  • Food Lovers Guide - Vanilla

    Plain vanilla extract is fine for large-batch baking, but vanilla snobs like to play with other varieties, including the skinny, leathery beans. We won’t delve into the classic Mexican-versus-Tahitian debate, except to say we like Tahitian for creamy concoctions and the bolder Mexican in concert with dark chocolate. Find plump, vacuum-sealed beans of both varieties at Surfas Culinary District. Read More

Expert Advice from Orange County's GrapeRadio Hosts
wine blog

stuff we love

Charitable Events Calendar