Orange Coast Magazine

Taste of O.C. | Priscilla Mayfield on food


Ever since reading Calvin Trillin on the subject, I’ve been intrigued by Cincinnati chili, a dish that’s sort of chili and sort of, well, something all its own. I recently got to try it for the first time, made by native Ohioan Marisa O’Neil, public information officer for OC Parks. Marisa and her 11-year-old son Liam are Trabuco Canyon neighbors of mine, and we had the chili for one of our “Downton Abbey” Sunday evenings, after the traditional G&Ts—gin and tonics. There’s just something about “Downton” and O.C., as I wrote previously in Taste of Orange County.

Not to mention, something about that chili. It is delicious. Supposedly created by a Macedonian immigrant restaurateur with a touch of the sweet spices allspice, cinnamon, and cloves, plus a little bitter chocolate, it’s more a savory sauce than the standard bowl o’ red. This makes perfect sense, because Cincinnati chili is traditionally served over spaghetti, with optional additions taking off from there. Chili on spaghetti is two-way. Three-way adds grated yellow cheese; four-way, onions; and five-way, kidney beans. With multiple additions, it’s like a looser, chunkier, snappy-flavored Bolognese. Really good.

Marisa’s Cincinnati chili has her personal customization as well: grass-fed beef. She’s a serious CrossFit athlete—like handstand-pushup serious, I mean—and tends to eat Paleo, with the occasional exception for Costco pizza. She makes her chili in a Ninja cooker, which sautés as well as slow cooks, but a regular slow cooker works great after the initial stovetop browning. The aforementioned Costco is also a good source for both grass-fed ground beef and chili powder.

Cincinnati Chili From Marisa O’Neil

(Makes about 8 servings)

1 tablespoon olive oil

½ cup chopped onion

2 pounds grass-fed ground beef

¼ cup chili powder

½ teaspoon allspice

¼ teaspoon cayenne

1 teaspoon cinnamon

½ teaspoon ground cloves

1 teaspoon ground cumin

1 bay leaf

1 ounce dark chocolate, at least 70 percent cacao

3 cups beef stock

1 15-ounce can tomato sauce

2 tablespoons cider vinegar

Cooked spaghetti

Grated cheddar cheese

Chopped onion

Cooked kidney beans

Heat a large saucepan, add oil, and sauté onion a few minutes, until translucent. Add beef and brown, breaking up chunks if necessary. Add chili powder, allspice, cayenne, cinnamon, cloves, cumin, bay leaf, chocolate, beef stock, tomato sauce, and vinegar. Bring to boil. Reduce heat and simmer 1 ½ hours, stirring occasionally. Or, transfer to slow cooker and cook on low about 6 hours.

Serve on hot cooked spaghetti with choice of additional toppings.


Leave a comment:

· Subscribe to comments
Be the first to comment here.

OC Guides


OC Guides
  • Neighborhoods: Rancho Santa Margarita

    Rancho Santa Margarita’s Plaza El Paseo is a South County suburban mall with a twist. It’s the unexpected finds—a little gem of a florist, cozy spots to sample tea and wine, and a top-notch steakhouse across the street—that put it in a league of its own. Read More
  • O.C.’s Best: Bloody Marys

    Get your vegetables and booze in one convenient—and delicious—serving with what’s been hailed as America’s murkiest and most complex cocktail. Traditionally made with tomato juice, vodka, celery salt, horseradish, Worcestershire, and Tabasco, its origins are widely debated. Here are five superb O.C. renditions of the world-famous drink.

    Read More
  • Hot O.C. Neighborhood: East Side Costa Mesa

    This updated neighborhood doesn’t have to try hard to be interesting, original, surprising, and modern—it just is. Take the mile-long stretch of strip malls along 17th Street, between Newport Boulevard and Irvine Avenue, the heart of the renaissance. Foodies come for the Instagram-worthy Aussie-style meat pies at PieNot, coconut French toast at Plums Café, and braised pork panini at Pitfire Artisan Pizza. And that’s just the Ps. Other homegrown restaurants and shops tip toward lean-and-clean fare, such as the casual Jan’s Health Bar. Plus it’s the birthplace of Mother’s Market & Kitchen. Read More
  • Hot O.C. Neighborhood: Downtown Anaheim

    With a focus on food and community, downtown’s fresh look gets inspiration from the city’s rural roots. It takes resourcefulness to restore and imaginatively reuse old buildings, qualities the city’s founding farming families had, too. The new energy is centered on the Packing District, a two-block stretch of Anaheim Boulevard between Santa Ana Street and East Broadway: the restored 1920s-era Packard Building, now home to Anaheim Brewery and Umami Burger, and the 1919 Anaheim Citrus Packing House, with a food hall of locally based food-and-beverage artisans. Read More
  • Neighborhoods: Costa Mesa

    Chain restaurants and stores dominate most of the strip malls on Costa Mesa’s east side. But at Santa Ana Avenue and 17th Street, look a little closer and you’ll find indie boutiques and cafes tucked in among the usual suspects Read More

Expert Advice from Orange County's GrapeRadio Hosts
wine blog

stuff we love

Charitable Events Calendar